Propane Locator

New York propane price: $2.57 per gallon (residential average, estimate). Week of Oct 12, 2026. U.S. average: $2.54. Source: Sample data (placeholder; EIA feed not yet connected). Updated Oct 14, 2026. SAMPLE DATA, NOT REAL PRICES.

Home › States › New York

New York Propane Prices: Tank Fill and Swap Costs Near You

Average residential propane in New York is $2.57/gal (+0.02 vs last week). Use it to estimate a home tank fill, then compare with cylinder swap/exchange prices nearby. Sample data

Sample data, not real prices. Placeholder estimates for preview only. Live EIA data is not connected yet.

Propane locations in New York

Real businesses, compiled Oct 19, 2026 from public company location pages and, where noted, directory listings (see Source). Only what the source states is shown; anything else is "Unknown". Call ahead to confirm services and prices.

Map of listed locations. Pins marked "approx." are placed at the city center. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Listed alphabetically by city.

Local Propane Companies with cylinder fill, swap/exchange

Propane locations in New York: tank exchange and fill (source-cited listings)
NameCityExchangeFillService typeExchange or swap priceTank with fuel in it priceFill per gallon priceSource
Suburban Propane76 Railroad Ave, Albany, NY 12205(518) 489-3271 Albany, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Albany139 Broadway, Albany, NY 12202(518) 449-2034 Albany, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Colonie2043-45 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12205(518) 456-7514 Albany, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
AmeriGas Propane9048 Route 9W, Athens, NY 12015(518) 943-3680 Athens, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane11400 New York 12, Boonville, NY 13309(315) 831-2121 Boonville, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane313 East Macarthur Ave Suite 1, Cobleskill, NY 12043(518) 234-3571 Cobleskill, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane3833 US Route 11, Cortland, NY 13045(607) 753-8248 Cortland, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane966 New York 34, Genoa, NY 13071(315) 497-3140 Genoa, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
U-Haul of Henrietta290 Jefferson Rd, Henrietta, NY 14623(585) 292-7000 Henrietta, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
Suburban Propane963 Chemung St, Horseheads, NY 14845(607) 739-4141 Horseheads, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Ridge Rd1875 E Ridge Rd, Irondequoit, NY 14622(585) 467-8330 Irondequoit, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
AmeriGas Propane20534 Rt. 411, La Fargeville, NY 13656(315) 658-2240 La Fargeville, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane6109 Robinson Rd, Lockport, NY 14094(716) 625-8282 Lockport, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane688 E Main St, Malone, NY 12953(518) 483-2710 Malone, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
Suburban Propane25 Kensico Dr, Mount Kisco, NY 10549(914) 666-5174 Mount Kisco, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
U-Haul of N Syracuse5967 E Taft Rd, North Syracuse, NY 13212(315) 458-3992 North Syracuse, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
AmeriGas Propane2256 County Route 8, Oswego, NY 13126(800) 263-7442 Oswego, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane361 South Junction Rd, Plattsburgh, NY 12901(518) 563-3430 Plattsburgh, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane3325 Chili Ave, Rochester, NY 14624(585) 889-3770 Rochester, NY Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane7 Mang Dr, Sidney, NY 13838(607) 563-2101 Sidney, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane524 Pine St, South Dayton, NY 14138(716) 988-3671 South Dayton, NY Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Teall Ave1001 Canal St, Syracuse, NY 13210(315) 474-2923 Syracuse, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Tonawanda2843 Kenmore Ave, Tonawanda, NY 14150(716) 874-6720 Tonawanda, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Orchard Park Rd3120 Orchard Park Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224(716) 675-9343 West Seneca, NY Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing

How to lower your propane cost

How much does it cost to fill a 5-gallon propane tank in New York?

About $18.42 for 5 gallons (5 x $3.683 per gallon), based on the EIA weekly residential propane price for New York, week of Oct 12, 2026. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Dealer prices vary; updates as new prices come in.

How much does it cost to fill a propane tank in New York?

Multiply the per-gallon price by the gallons you need. A 500-gallon home tank is filled to about 80% (400 gallons), so at the shown average price that is roughly 400 x the price. Delivery fees and minimums vary by dealer.

Is a tank swap (exchange) cheaper than a refill?

Usually not per gallon. A 20 lb exchange cylinder often holds about 15 lb (about 3.5 gallons), so refilling at a dealer is typically cheaper per gallon. Exchange is faster and more convenient.

When is propane cheapest?

Prices usually dip in late spring and summer. Filling or pre-buying a season contract before October can lower your cost.

How can I lower my propane cost?

Compare dealers, ask about budget or pre-buy plans, own your tank so you can shop around, and improve insulation and thermostat settings.

Data & links

Nearby states