Propane Locator

Indiana propane price: $2.51 per gallon (residential average, estimate). Week of Oct 12, 2026. U.S. average: $2.54. Source: Sample data (placeholder; EIA feed not yet connected). Updated Oct 14, 2026. SAMPLE DATA, NOT REAL PRICES.

Home › States › Indiana

Indiana Propane Prices: Tank Fill and Swap Costs Near You

Average residential propane in Indiana is $2.51/gal (+0.02 vs last week). Use it to estimate a home tank fill, then compare with cylinder swap/exchange prices nearby. Sample data

Sample data, not real prices. Placeholder estimates for preview only. Live EIA data is not connected yet.

Propane locations in Indiana

Real businesses, compiled Oct 19, 2026 from public company location pages and, where noted, directory listings (see Source). Only what the source states is shown; anything else is "Unknown". Call ahead to confirm services and prices.

Map of listed locations. Pins marked "approx." are placed at the city center. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Listed alphabetically by city.

Local Propane Companies with cylinder fill, swap/exchange

Propane locations in Indiana: tank exchange and fill (source-cited listings)
NameCityExchangeFillService typeExchange or swap priceTank with fuel in it priceFill per gallon priceSource
Suburban Propane3871 W State Road 54, Bloomfield, IN 47424(812) 659-3531 Bloomfield, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane375 West Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112(317) 852-8916 Brownsburg, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane231 South St, Darlington, IN 47940(888) 708-2508 Darlington, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane1024 E US Highway 224, Decatur, IN 46733(260) 724-3716 Decatur, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
U-Haul of Elkhart29057 Old US Hwy 33, Elkhart, IN 46516(574) 295-3986 Elkhart, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Evansville1200 E Riverside Dr, Evansville, IN 47714(812) 477-5561 Evansville, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Glenbrook4611 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825(260) 483-1165 Fort Wayne, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Downtown808 E Washington Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46803(260) 424-7724 Fort Wayne, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Eagledale2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222(317) 923-1508 Indianapolis, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Southern Plaza4011 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227(317) 787-6368 Indianapolis, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
Suburban Propane6101 Hamburg Pike, Jeffersonville, IN 47130(812) 282-1311 Jeffersonville, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane5695 East US Hwy 6 W, Kendallville, IN 46755(260) 347-2266 Kendallville, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane624 South Berkley Rd, Kokomo, IN 46901(765) 459-3141 Kokomo, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane5010 N Post Rd, Lawrence, IN 46226(317) 898-7212 Lawrence, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane894 Indiana 67, Martinsville, IN 46151(765) 342-0604 Martinsville, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane6088 State Road 46 E, Nashville, IN 47448(812) 988-4503 Nashville, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page
AmeriGas Propane215 South Sycamore St, Osgood, IN 47037(812) 689-5020 Osgood, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
AmeriGas Propane25701 Indiana 2, South Bend, IN 46619(800) 530-6704 South Bend, IN Unknown Yes (delivery) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Bend3410 Western Ave, South Bend, IN 46619(574) 282-2801 South Bend, IN Unknown Yes (refill station) Refill station; exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown U-Haul "Propane Refill Stations" listing
AmeriGas Propane804 Morthland Dr, Valparaiso, IN 46383(219) 462-3187 Valparaiso, IN Unknown Yes (delivery and tank refills) Delivery (tank fill); exchange unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown AmeriGas office page
Suburban Propane2752 S US Highway 35, Winamac, IN 46996(260) 672-9710 Winamac, IN Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Suburban Propane all-locations page

How to lower your propane cost

How much does it cost to fill a 5-gallon propane tank in Indiana?

About $12.45 for 5 gallons (5 x $2.490 per gallon), based on the EIA weekly residential propane price for Indiana, week of Oct 12, 2026. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Dealer prices vary; updates as new prices come in.

How much does it cost to fill a propane tank in Indiana?

Multiply the per-gallon price by the gallons you need. A 500-gallon home tank is filled to about 80% (400 gallons), so at the shown average price that is roughly 400 x the price. Delivery fees and minimums vary by dealer.

Is a tank swap (exchange) cheaper than a refill?

Usually not per gallon. A 20 lb exchange cylinder often holds about 15 lb (about 3.5 gallons), so refilling at a dealer is typically cheaper per gallon. Exchange is faster and more convenient.

When is propane cheapest?

Prices usually dip in late spring and summer. Filling or pre-buying a season contract before October can lower your cost.

How can I lower my propane cost?

Compare dealers, ask about budget or pre-buy plans, own your tank so you can shop around, and improve insulation and thermostat settings.

Data & links

Nearby states